Monday, November 21, 2011

Dear Leader, President Zuma - Road carnage

On a breakfast program this morning our President gave a solemn undertaking that citizens who have had useful ideas spurned in the past should come forward and elaborate. He guaranteed that these ideas would be reviewed as the current National Plan is intended to be fully inclusive.

Road Carnage
On 23 December 2010, the networks carried yet another story about the carnage on our roads. Some 20 persons had perished in a taxi pile up. Since that date the carnage has continued unrelentingly. By 27 Dec 2001 the number of persons killed was over 900.
The point to be made is that we are world leaders in the business of killing and maiming human beings on our roads, and have been for many years.
And for all these years we have indulged ourselves in crying, moaning, groaning … etc about the problem whilst perpetuating stratagems that have always been doomed to failure.
In late 2003 a certain female educator was accorded an audience with the functionary, charged with responsibility for Road Safety stratagems, at Department of Transport.
The then ailing Minister, Dullah Omar, had expressed great interest in what she had to offer, to the extent of extending her an invitation to attend a Road Safety symposium that he sponsored.
She had an educational product, devised over a long period, titled “RoadSafe”. It was multifaceted, and Outcome Based Education aligned. It rested on certain fundamental realities including –
a) current stratagems, prosecuted under Arrive Alive, were guaranteed to be ineffective (that much was already just about agreed by all except Arrive Alive itself);
b) concomitantly “more police”, “harsher penalties” and other “let’s be more draconian” measures were also doomed to failure;
c) the reason being, the simple but fundamental one, that the whole problem was steeped in a deviant road use culture;
d) which culture needed to be addressed on all fronts, starting in the schools where being “RoadSafe” should be embedded as a subject like any other.
As a starting point she had devised a board game for children as “tactile” experience is so important in a child’s learning experience.
The product however encompassed an approach that would involve all sectors of society as a “national’ commitment to “change road use culture” to one that was “RoadSafe” so that the concept, name and attitude became as natural as breathing over time; ingrained, embedded in the psyche of upcoming drivers in particular.

The paradigm proposition was that to continue as we were was equivalent to treating acne or other skin disorder with soap and creams when the underlining cause is a blood disorder.
Insanity: doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results.
Albert Einstein
Her product had received the enthusiastic endorsement of the CSIR. That’s right. This important scientific government agency gave the “RoadSafe” its full endorsement.

The good lady was shown the door, after a short sharp lecture by the relevant female functionary at DOT, that she should understand that “we have our own programs …”

Eight (8) years have now been lost. During that time the road use culture has not changed one jot and thousands of people have been killed, injured, mothers widowed, children orphaned.

CSIR filed its recommendation. Minister Omar has sadly passed on. The “RoadSafe” concept/brand
sits on a computer in a suburban home in Pretoria, whilst mayhem rules on our roads.

What has also happened since the date she was shown the door is that an entity titled the Road Traffic Management Corporation (RTMC) has come into existence. Road carnage has continued. Interviewed by Jeremy Maggs on eTV on the 28th Dec 2011, the Acting CEO of the RTMC promised "viciousness" as a strategy to the problem. God help us Mr President! Maggs was constrained to point out to him that it was road use culture that was/is the problem!

So Mr President, might we take you up on your word, and draw your attention to this instance where being "unconnected politically" guaranteed that your useful voice as a citizen remained unheard.

 Current stratagems are proving hopelessly ineffective. The cost to the country needs no elaboration. It is horrendous on every count. This was predicted at the time the good lady was shown the door by the functionary at the Department of Transport.

Mr President, also please note that when we submit ideas to ANC branches, we do not receive so much as an acknowledgment, ever!

______________________________________________________

PostScript --- this was submitted to the President's Office, ANC Head Office, Gauteng Branch and SABC 2 on 21-22 Nov 2011. Not so much as an acknowledgement was received as at 27 Dec 2011. The SABC 2 breakfast show was thus no more than yet another pantomine, We are voiceless on this new animal farm.

In the meantime the death toll for the Xmas period was over 900 killed and thousands injured as at 27 Dec 2011.

Thursday, November 3, 2011

South Africa -- Constitutional Democracy under attack by ANC leaders


In a previous blog post "Dubula ibhunu --- (Kill the Boer song) A Nation in Trouble" I had taken the stance that South Africa was in serious trouble, as it was apparent that leadership had little understanding of the imperatives of a constitutional democracy and that the President continues to be very badly advised. 

That I was not wrong is now beyond question in terms of the following (per Pretoria News 28 Sep 2011).

ANC CHIEF Whip Mathole Motshekga fired a shot across the Constitutional Court’s bow warning the highest court in the land to stay out of the fight over the controversial Protection of Information Bill.

Speaking to Jeremy Maggs on the E.News channel Motshekga went on to say that the ANC would not countenance the court striking down the Bill once passed by the ANC in Parliament.

“If people are defeated in a political arena, they want to substitute the will of the people with the will of the judges. Then we must redefine our democracy and how we want to manage our country” he responded. "It is not for judges to decide for Parliament, because that would be a gross violation" he said.
It should be remembered that the President had previously said at a conference of judges that - “the powers of the courts cannot be superior to the powers resulting from the political and consequently administrative mandate resulting from popular democratic elections”.
"Zuma is criticising the Constitutional Court, saying (as the old National Party did in 1953) that it should not be above the sovereignty of Parliament; members of the South African Communist Party seemingly agree, contending that the constitution itself is outdated and should be changed, while Deputy President Kgalema Motlanthe declares it is sacred and the very bedrock of our democracy.
These are not mere disagreements on policy, and there are plenty of those. They are fundamental differences over the very nature of the state — as fundamental as it is possible to get in politics. What Zuma and the South African Communist Party are saying amounts to a repudiation of the covenant entered into by all parties at the Convention for a Democratic SA and consecrated by Nelson Mandela in his historic inaugural address in 1994.
A covenant to declare the new S A a constitutional democracy, in which the constitution is the supreme law to which all citizens, including MPs, Cabinet ministers and the president himself, are subject". [per Alastair Sparkd @ http://www.businessday.co.za/articles/Content.aspx?id=161501]
To date, the media has taken the stance that this constitutional democracy "may" be under threat. No one should be confused any longer; it is not under threat; it is under attack; robust, aggressive attack; and the ANC Chief Whip has served notice that the Constitution will be scrapped to remove the doctrine of separation of powers.

As a former judge, I am able to say with considerable confidence that the Protection Of information Bill, in its current state, has very little chance of surviving a court challenge. The Constitution requires the very opposite of what the Bill is attempting. It insists that information be made available, not restricted.

So we are being given due notice that when the courts do their job and strike down the bill, wholly or in part, the ANC will not accept this and will scrap the constitution to rid it of the separation of powers.

In a nutshell, what the Chief Whip is saying is that the courts are not there to countermand the will of the majority party - - even if the majority is wrong. A good example is the issue of the death penalty. 84% of South Africans support the death penalty, but the courts ruled against this. The decision of the courts has been accepted even though it is completely against the will of most people, let alone the ANC!

So, at a stroke, we can see that the ANC wants to have a situation where IT has a prerogative to "pick and choose" which court decisions it will accept -- AND also an unfettered right to decide what is the law, what is the rule of law, what are human rights .. NOT the courts!

We should all understand that the very essence of a constitutional democracy, and the doctrine of separation powers, is to ensure that all human beings, even the very lowliest, are protected  -- protected even against the will of the majority if necessary. It is often necessary. History has shown that the majority is often wrong. Just ask Socrates and Aristotle, persecuted for their brilliant minds of disagreement with the majority.

The passion with which the ANC wants to be able to conceal information is extremely worrisome considering that nothing has happened to date that indicates a need for concealment.

What we need to understand very clearly is that, although the Bill has been reported as "anti media", it is actually about shutting up and gagging ordinary citizens. The media are making a fuss simply because they deal in selling information. But this is about dumping our right to free speech in very large measure. So you stand to be imprisoned for that sms, tweet, FB post or any statement made in whatever form - if some faceless bureaucrat has classified the info as secret, whether you know of such classification or not.
So, South Africans. Take Note!. This is called the tyranny of might is right!


Judicial Independence
On 2 November 2011, this what President Jacob Zuma included in his speech at the farewell dinner for the outgoing Chief Justice:

 “Our view is that the Executive, as elected officials, has the sole discretion to decide policies for government. I know that the last time we raised this point, we generated a heated debate within the legal fraternity, some of whom did not see that it was actually an affirmation of the doctrine of the separation of powers.

This challenge is perhaps articulated clearly by Justice VR Krishna Lyer of India who observed that: "Legality is within the courts' province to pronounce upon, but canons of political propriety and democratic dharma are polemic issues on which judicial silence is the golden rule."

In our view, the principle of separation of powers means that we should discourage the encroachment of one arm of the State on the terrain of another, and there must be no bias in this regard.

We respect the powers and role conferred by our Constitution on the legislature and the judiciary. At the same time, we expect the same from these very important institutions of our democratic dispensation.

The Executive must be allowed to conduct its administration and policy making work as freely as it possibly can. The powers conferred on the courts cannot be regarded as superior to the powers resulting from a mandate given by the people in a popular vote. 

We also reiterate that in order to provide support to the judiciary and free our courts to do their work, it would help if political disputes were resolved politically. We must not get a sense that there are those who wish to co-govern the country through the courts, when they have not won the popular vote during elections. This interferes with the independence of the judiciary.”

This now perhaps the 4th time that the President has felt compelled to lecture the judiciary on the matter of what is known as the "doctrine of separation of powers".

This is highly problematical, for the simple but very good reason that any judge who does not understand this doctrine should not be on the Bench of the Superior Courts. A judge who does not understand this is incompetent. A medical analogy would be that a doctor who does not understand what "intravenous" means would be incompetent. It is that basic. We can accept, beyond doubt, that the President does not believe that the judges are incompetent. So why these repeated admonitions?

Regrettably all the indications are that the Executive does not understand the doctrine as it applies in a constitutional democracy and/or is resolved in rejection. This is the only reasonable inference that one is compelled to draw on the evidence to date. It explains the repeated "warnings" to the judiciary.

These "warnings" will now have the following regrettable knock on effects: -
a)  Judges will undoubtedly interpret the situation correctly, and know that they are under scrutiny on the issue of being either "on side" or "off side" in relation to the Executive.

b)  As judges are human beings, they will experience conscious and/or subconscious pressure to comply with the wishes of the Executive.

c)  This, in turn, will induce conscious or subconscious bias in judicial approach, either "for" or "against" the Executive. 
d)  The recent controversial appointment of new Chief Justice will inevitably be seen as having been driven by a political imperative to have an "onside" judiciary.

e)  For the incumbent, it regrettably impacts negatively on his credibility and the issue of bias will have a subverting effect on his functionality both subjectively and objectively, regardless of how functionally independent he actually is.

f)   Should there be another split decision, like the one in which the Executive’s disbanding of the Scorpions was reversed, perception of a judiciary being split along "pro/against" the Executive lines will receive a huge boost.

g)  If the majority in such split decision turns out to be led by the new Chief Justice, the perception will be that the judiciary is now beholden to the Executive and no longer independent, regardless of whether or not the decision is jurisprudentially sound.

h)  In this way the credibility and stature of the judiciary will be comprehensively subverted and/or destroyed, locally and internationally. 

i)   For judges this will mean loss of stature and prestige. For the country this will also mean loss of stature, credibility and prestige. This will have a serious eroding effect on investor confidence.   

j)   The organically induced disrespect for the courts will have an insidiously aggravating on the climate of anomie that has undoubtedly had this country in its grip for decades now.

Observations:
There can be little doubt that the President continues to be very ill advised. It must be hoped that to-day’s appointment of Michael Hulley, as his legal advisor, will redress this situation. There are three (3) cardinal issues that Michael Hulley needs to make the Executive understand.

 (1) In a constitutional democracy the sacred duty of the judiciary is to jealously guard the letter and spirit of the constitution against all comers, including the Executive.

 (2) The inevitable consequence of this is that the Courts can, and must, overturn the will of the majority, even when passed by Act of Parliament. In any event, history has repeatedly shown that the majority is often wrong, badly wrong. It was the majority who screamed “"crucify Him, crucify Him". Two of the greatest minds in history Socrates and Aristotle were persecuted by the majority for saying that planet Erath was flat and revolved around the Sun. Socrates was put to death Aristotle had to flee.
"A word like ‘tyranny’ is interesting for its inevitable conjuring up of concerns about the tyranny of the majority, a misstep of democracy that judges – in their independence from the political process – are able to correct."       Writer Chris Geidner .   Commentary on the court decision overturning California’s Prop 8  In the Gay & Lesbian News Magazine.
 (3) As much as government may wish to have issues “"politically" resolved, every citizen, even the lowliest, has an absolute right to take a matter to court if he/she thinks, believes, even just imagines that the court’s protection/intervention is needed. The Courts have a very well established procedure for dealing with matters that are improperly brought, including summary rejection on the basis of being frivolous and/or vexatious, and punishing the applicant. That right therefore, does not stand t be questioned.


Monday, October 31, 2011

Lindiwe Mazibuko --- colour blind disciple of social justice

This beautiful, personable lady was interviewed by Leanne Manas on eTV this morning, 31 Oct 2011, on her success in securing leadership of the Democratic Alliance in Parliament.

Understandably she was heartily congratulated on her success, which congratulations she graciously accepted.

She was also propositioned, in countless different ways, on the issues of race, ethnicity and skin colour. That is where South Africa is to-day, after some 17 years since apartheid was deposed as government culture. Its not about her vision as leader in Parliament of the Opposition, but about her ethnicity??

As repeatedly pointed out in blog posts the national psyche of South Africa is infused with race, ethnicity and skin colour. It is a preoccupation and obsession that is eating away at the national psyche like a cancer, destroying progress towards nation building.

Because the colour “black” was posted as the central criteria for a human being to qualify for redress from apartheid disadvantage, under our Affirmative Action and other transformational models, there is now an inarticulate proposition in the subconscious mind of the nation that “Black good, White bad, Coloured/Indian/Chinese not too good”. This is the exact converse of what was at the heart of apartheid culture. 17 years after apartheid it is assumed that every Black person is disadvantaged in relation to every White person, even if such Black person is a billionaire. This has ensured that a "connected" Black elite is amassing fabulous wealth whilst the majority remain stuck in apartheid style poverty. 

The obsession has been evidenced by continual incidents of a subsisting racist culture in the corridors of power. Notable examples are Mike Stofile bitterly complaining that there was no place for Blacks in SARU after being beaten in a democratic election for the presidency of the South Africa Rugby Union by Oregan Hoskins, a Coloured. "I've been saying for four years now there is no place for black people in SA rugby and this is the final nail for black people in this country” Stofile lamented. As a Coloured Organ Hoskins had no right to oppose a Black.

Later there was the Jimmy Manyi saga, in which our chief government spokesman was shown on tape holding to the considered view that “there were too many Coloureds in the Western Cape … and that they should migrate to other provinces”. Cabinet then had to backtrack on a Bill that it had signed off on, which was designed to force Coloured migration from the Western Cape as employers would be forced to dump them in the workplace.

Despite such back tracking, the Department of Correctional Services has just been exposed for implementing a policy to give effect to the Jimmy Manyi racist doctrine. Manyi had also insulted Indians by postulating that they were “over-represented” at management level on account of their “economic influence”.

Just last week, none other than Julius Malema, flag waving populist leader of the ANC youth League, condescended to apologize for referring to Indians as “coolies”, a derogatory term. His apology sufficed. No other sanction, let alone condemnation, accrued. However he has declined to apologize for referring the Whites as "criminals" and “thieves”. Not so as regards Darren Scott, ace media sports anchor who was fired for calling a Black colleague a “kaffir”, also a derogatory term. The difference in the Malema and Scott incidents is that Scott is White and Malema is Black. As a Black person, Malema is “more equal” than Scott on our new “animal farm”, and his racist comments therefore more tolerable and unremarkable.

Leanne Manas did her job as a media journo. She put it to Lindiwe that there was a veritable deluge of comment from various Black spokespersons that she was simply not perceived as Black or Black enough! She put it in a dozen different ways, including the allegation that Lindiwe was a “coconut”, i.e., black/brown on the outside but with a “white” mentality. A long indictment from the "thinking like a black" camp was put to her. 

To her immense credit our good lady, Lindiwe Mazibuko, disregarded the accusations and declined to dignify them with any kind of  response. With the ease and grace of a person of immense emotional intelligence she simply declined to be dragged down into the pernicious quagmire of this obscene discourse and stuck to what matters in present day South Africa, i.e., the now dire needs of our people. Not once did she mention the word “black”, despite the very pointed nature of the questions put. It never appeared, for a nano second, that she would be distracted by this nonsense. Instead she spoke to the needs of our people and how she imagined that she and her party would be able to address those needs. To her, it is all about failed delivery, human misery and what needs to be done. It is all about hope for the future.

All right thinking citizens of South Africa, in particular, must salute this young lady. Not only is she educated, personable and skilled, she also has that most precious commodity, understanding. She understands that in a constitutional democracy race, ethnicity, skin colour are irrelevant. What is relevant is social justice. She understands, in particular, that you do not take the blindfold off Lady Justice and ask her to see differences in the race and ethnicity of human beings. She knows that to do so guarantees deterioration to systemic discrimination, victimization and other forms of injustice, such as xenophobia, as we have experienced in South Africa at horrendous levels.

Lindiwe Mazibuko, we salute you. You are a new brand of leader. You are refusing to turn South Africa into an “animal farm” in which some are “more equal than others”. You have understanding; understanding of the realities, understanding of human rights; understanding of social justice. You share this understanding with your illustrious colleagues Helen Zille and Patrica de Lille. It in this brand of leadership that provides hope for the future of this incredible country.

It is the hope that Martin Luther King Jr adverted to in his “I Have a Dream” speech and Nelson Rolihlahla Mandela imagined in his “Never Again” speech.

Wednesday, October 26, 2011

Justice --- must inform thinking

Justice (or fairness) is a word that is bandied about at all levels and is often used with great passion. We all imagine that, when we use the word “justice”, we mean what we say and say what we mean. It is also behind what we believe is right and what we think is wrong. It is fundamental because everyone will agree that, without it, life is intolerable. We don’t have to think about it … instinctively we all know that it is something we all must have … as human beings.
But do we know what justice is? Most people, when asked “what is justice?” will have trouble defining it, even though it is absolutely fundamental to human relations. I base this on actual experience in addressing human groups.
Despite this, people will enthusiastically, aggressively and even violently take a stance on what is wrong, or right, fair or unfair. We see this daily in Face Book discussions for instance, whether its about the killing of Muammar Gaddafi, the so called “land reform” in Zimbabwe, the treatment of Gays and Lesbians, the Israel/Palestinian conflict and a plethora of  other local and international affairs.
It is very frustrating to read the discussions, because they usually end the way they start, with each side still locked into the self righteous position they started with, after sometimes bitter "point scoring", regardless of what the opponent advances. The reason why parties to a debate stay locked in their positions is usually because the paradigm thinking, driving their stance, is steeped in religion, culture and/or political persuasion. Politics, culture and religion are boxes in which people find and keep themselves --- often with pride and great passion.
So we really need something that takes all of us out of our respective boxes, if any progress is to be made. These boxes can’t all be right … all of the time. After all, which box you find yourself in is usually a matter of pure chance, over which we have no control. You do not choose to be born Black. You will become a Moslem only because of where and to whom you were born. So too as regards whether you are an American or a Tswana, or Ndebele or Shona. It is all dependent on pure chance. And yet, we lock ourselves into the box in which we find ourselves in, espouse its gospel and imagine that we are right! Wow! How very silly we are. Really!
The religious box is perhaps the most pernicious. Religion is handed down from generation to generation almost exclusively by parents to their children. These children embrace the religion on account of parental influence and the environment they find themselves in. None of this occurs on account of any substantive cognitive process. And yet, generation after generation accepts unconditionally that their religion is "right" to the extent regrettably of being prepared to victimize, even kill, others in its defense and/or propagation. It is the most obscene/grotesque reality that more human beings have been killed and maimed in the name of religion than for any other cause.  It is obscene and grotesque because all major religions preach peace and love of humanity. 
What we need is something that is divested of our own box; something that applies regardless of race, ethnicity, religion, colour or creed.
Lady Justice
 Might I introduce you to this lady. She is beautiful; as beautiful as we all imagine justice to be. So feel free to ascribe her the beauty that you ascribe justice. She is called Lady Justice. 
What you will notice is that she has a sword in one hand. This is because, at a certain point, justice demands that there be punishment, sometimes very severe punishment. No one disagrees on this.
You will also notice that, in her other hand, she holds a set of scales.  This is where she weighs up the dispute. When we argue with each other we are insisting on what should go into these scales. Lady Justice puts us, and our arguments, in  the scales --- and proceeds to resolve the dispute by making sure that they are in a balance – neither having more than the other. Whatever else we may disagree on, we all agree that justice only occurs if, in the end, neither has more than the other. So that is why she has the scales; to ensure this balance.
Most importantly however, we see that Lady Justice is blindfolded! She was not always blindfolded. In her original version, as the Greek Lady, Thermis, she was not blindfolded.
Originally, at the time of the Greek goddess Thermis, and her daughter Dike, there was no connection between the notion of justice and that of fairness. Justice was a matter of fate, providence or in terms of the will of the gods. So untimely death, illness (even wealth and poverty) or other misfortune was seen as God’s will, fate, providence, or just being cursed.
 However conflict and human misery, experienced over centuries, proved, beyond all doubt, that she needed to be blindfolded, otherwise there would be still no justice.  Over many centuries man came to the realization that, in order for Lady Justice to do her job properly, she needed to be blind to the racial, cultural, ethnic, tribal, religious, social, political and other differences of those appearing before her.
Unless she was blind to difference there would never be justice. This realization is encapsulated in the 1948 United Nations Universal Declaration Of Human Rights, which absolutely outlaws distinctions based on status. Such differences are irrelevant to the sacred business of weighing up the disputants and their claims in her scales. Lady Justice does not see the box that you are in. 
All are equal before her. All are equal before her. All are equal before her.
The fact that you are a senior politician, or even a President, does not make your defense to a claim by a humble peasant any stronger. The fact that you are a Ndebele does not make you right and your Shona adversary wrong. The fact that you are ZANU-PF does not mean that your policy is more fair or just than that of the MDC. These “boxes” are simply irrelevant to the issue of justice, or fairness, or right and wrong.
In the result we must all agree with Malcolm X that --“I'm for truth, no matter who tells it. I'm for justice, no matter who it's for or against”.             
 “Justice and power must be brought together, so that whatever is just may be powerful, and whatever is powerful may be just". Blaise Pascal (French Mathematician, Philosopher and Physicist, 1623 – 1662”
“Injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere”. Martin Luther King (Baptist Minister)1929 - 1968
“In matters of truth and justice, there is no difference between large and small problems, for issues concerning the treatment of people are all the same”         Albert Einstein (Physicist)1879–18 April 1955
All of these statements need to be studied very carefully, considered and embraced, unconditionally . When you do, you need to first take yourself out of the box that you are in. The fact that you are Conservative or a Democrat, ZANU-PF or MDC,  Christian or a Moslem, Jew or Palestinian, Ndebele or a Shona, Black or a White .. etc ... are simply irrelevant.
You need to see your opponent, through clear eyes, simply as your equal, because Lady Justice does not see any difference between you.
Then you need to ask yourself the question. Do you love him/her as you love yourself … and/or … are you treating him/her as you would want to be treated.
 It is that simple. Really!
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Order --- theother.orgfree.com.




Please share.

Friday, September 16, 2011

The Coloured Issue --- dealing in lies

This issue needs to be settled, dispassionately. It is important on a number of counts, especially as it now reposes very much in a “growth sector”, as the different races find that opposites attract and that there is real magic in difference. Some are even mooting the proposition that the World’s populace will sooner, rather than later, be a nice shade of honey brown.

It is important also because, in microcosm, it is a touchstone on which propositions of social justice are tested. These range from tribalistic attitudes to broader matters of social engineering.
“Since Coloured people are neither truly white, brown nor black, a government obsessed with colour as a basic criterion in the treatment of human beings, is tripped up and confused about what to do. So it resorts to makeshift and unprincipled solutions like artificially defining all "non-white" people as Black. The consequences for us Coloured people are organically induced challenges, ever present, hardly acknowledged; in a minefield of obfuscation”.1

In May, 2011 a film was screened titled “I'm Not Black, I'm Coloured”, Identity Crisis at the Cape of Good Hope” by Mondé World Films  depicting the plight of Coloured folk in the new South Africa, on account of an inherently racist Affirmative Action transformational model.2

Monde Films was quickly vindicated when it was revealed that chief South African government spokesman, Jimmy Manyi, had insisted there was an “oversupply” of Coloureds in the Western Cape and suggested they “spread in the rest of the country”. He said their “over-concentration” in the province “is not working for them”. The comments were made in April during a debate about affirmative action that appeared on KykNet’s Robinson Regstreeks show.

At a stroke this chief government spokesman gave the lie to the pretence that Coloured folk were regarded and accepted as Black. He let the cat out of the bag. Claimed government policy was a hypocritical lie. This was confirmed when the government then signed off on a Bill that would have had the effect of forcing employers to dump an estimated one million Coloureds in the Western Cape, on the basis that they were not, in fact, Black.

So we know that it is a legitimate issue. Like all such issues there are consequences if mishandled, sometimes dreadful consequences. Is the issue being mishandled? 

The answer is Yes. It is yes as regards Coloured folk being labelled as Black, and pressured into acceptance of the label by societal attitudes and verbalization.

South Africa is a quintessential example in that, amongst other things, Coloured folk are being denied the attainment of social justice, under its transformational model, unless they claim and prove that they are Black, even if they are visually "snow white" with green eyes.
For rejecting this classification, I have been roundly condemned by even my most trusted and respected of Black friends. A Namibian judicial officer, who I hold in the highest regard, said he just could not believe that, especially as I was a Judge, I could/would not accept a now internationally accepted social norm that there is no such thing as “Coloured”. You are either White or you are Black. This was more or less repeated just yesterday by a revered Face Book friend who assured me that this was most certainly the situation in Europe.

To these of my friends, and all others who understandably hold to this view I have this to say. You have unwittingly joined a world in which dealing in “convenient untruths” is a now a norm at pandemic levels. There are innumerable examples of this. We have witnessed them being listed on our site, lies damned lies, ranging from historical distortions to blatant propaganda, whether it be about why Iraq was invaded to Ian Smith saving Rhodesia from communism.

You see the statement that nearly all Coloured folk regard themselves as Black is simply untrue. If you accept that a Coloured person is anyone who also has African blood in his/her veins, you will quickly realize that there are millions of human beings on this planet who have the now notorious “one drop of black blood” in their veins but do not regard themselves as Black for a nanosecond. Neither are they regarded as Black. It is an open secret that most White Afrikaners in South Africa fall into this category. Facts are awkward things, when you are sucked into accepting lies.

I am not Black. That is a simple fact, that even a five-year-old child will confirm to you without the slightest hesitation. More importantly I am anthropologically not Black. Genetically I am Euro-African, anthropologically 50% Caucasian and 50% African. That is a fact. It is the reality. It cannot be denied, wished away, obfuscated or rationalized into something else!
To say or pretend otherwise is to propagate a lie. Lies are bad. I was first taught this by my African grandmother, Mafulela Thebe.

“I loved being at my granny's village, comprising a cluster of pole and dagga huts with thatched roofs. However, I was extremely resentful of the fact that all those around me were black and I was brown. Also my hair was almost completely straight. This induced a serious identity crisis. When my mother arrived to fetch me she called me by name Vavie. I protested bitterly and tearfully in isiNdebele - "I am not Vavie. I am Ndiweni ... Me I am Ndiweni""
My grandmother was not impressed. She explained that I was not "umuntu um'nyama" [a black person]- that I was "umlungu" [of White status patrilineally ] - that I should never forget this and be proud of what I was, otherwise she would have to use a switch to get me to understand”.1


However my friends are right. All over the world Coloured folk are referred to as Black. Millions refer to themselves as Black. President Barrack Obama, Euro-African like me, is also referred to as Black, even though he was actually brought up by a White grandmother.
It is symptomatic of the extent to which our world deals in lies. This one is understandable. It is called a “social construct”.3 
 
Social construct is a convenient label.  Packaging is everything.  It cloaks the thing in legitimacy. It makes the lie acceptable, even desirable, as my friends insist.

So why do I reject the thing?  Why do I seemingly refuse to accept reality?  Why swim against the tide? Why be stubborn?  Why be unrealistic?  Why do I refuse to accept the label "Black"? 
Might I ask all of you to put the following statement to any competent psychologist or criminologist.

“Judge Chris Greenland claims that self image is deeply embedded in the human psyche. It is critical to human development. Confusion around issues of self image are inherently dangerous and can, in the longer term, stunt development, induce personality aberrations and inhibit the realization of potential. There is a direct correlation between deviance and criminality, on the one hand, and such confusion, on the other.”.

You will not find one reputable psychologist or criminologist that will disagree with that statement. So there you have it. If you want to bugger up your children psychologically, go along with the lie. Children can absolutely differentiate between lies and truth.  The experts will also confirm this. Children know when you are lying. They have eyes. They can see themselves in the mirror. They do not appreciate the fact that it is not regarded as a lie because it is packaged as a “social construct”.
The experts will also confirm that what is actually needed is acceptance of what and who you are in a culture of self-pride. To influence a brown child that he/she is black is to force a lie on the child, induce confusion, destroy such acceptance and inhibit self-pride. It is a very dangerous business.

It is, of course, quite obscenely ironic that the social construct is a product of racism. It is a legacy from an era in the United States when all non-white folk where forced into one camp, on account of rejection by the dominant White group. You were to be labelled black, whatever your actual skin colour, on account of the fact that you had just “one drop” of African blood. Since anything black was so bad you were to be cast into the larger Black pool of the rejected, despised, humiliated and abused! It is this diabolical legacy that now informs the so-called social construct. We have embraced the infamous “one drop” rule and made it our own. Wow!

My friend Tendai has said – “I am in a relationship with a white girl and you need to understand that our children are not going to be brought up as anything but Black!”
Tendai you are red carded … voted off the island … for firstly displaying typical African male historical chauvinism and secondly, racism. Yes – racism, with respect! You see the definition of racism includes not according another human being full recognition on account of their ethnicity. To accord your wife’s ethnicity absolutely no value in the ethnicity of your child is racist. Worst still you will seek to impose this perspective on your child! A racist culture is going to be added to the confusion the child will be already experiencing. The child needs to be imbued with pride about each of his/her parents, and pride in his/herself for being part of both – not one!

Miss-identification with one parent can have a very profound consequence. For instance, if a male child adopts a father image of its mother before the age of six, this can cause it to become homosexual.
So can I invite you to be concerned with truth, not lies and not play dangerous games with your children? This does not mean that your child will not grow up to regard himself/herself as Black or identify with Black causes. Conversely, the child may grow up to regard himself/herself as White … or Brown, like me.
However, it will be a choice made by a child imbued with a sense of self-acceptance and pride. It will be an informed choice shaped by other societal factors that present in its environment. It will do so in its own interests, especially on account of what gives him/her the greatest sense of belonging.


A sense of belonging is important. Personally I have always felt that I belong to the larger Black community.
This is understandable. Like millions of other Coloured Zimbabweans, I was welcomed into this world by the Black community and given love and comfort. Later I was liberated by mostly Black freedom fighters. The fight against racist oppression was captained by Blacks, like Martin Luther King Jr and Nelson Rolihlahla Mandela. I, therefore, have been drawn into that community by real-life experiences. I can belong there without lying about who and what I am.

When I look at my life I am happy with it.  I think I did good. I am forever indebted to my Black grandmother for having given me a very good start in life, by insisting that I accept who and what am.
Minority groups, all over the World, need to find the label that best fits their self image and accords with truth. They should not accept what is conveniently forced on them by dominant groups. They must insist that they are accepted for who and what they actually are! . In Zimbabwe we are referred to by the Black majority as "makhaaradis”, (Coloureds). Wonderful!!!!

“I am not a little bit of many things; but I am the sufficient representation of many things. I am not an incompletion of all these races; but I am a masterpiece of the prolific. I am an entirety, I am not a lack of anything; rather I am a whole of many things. God did not see it needful to make me generic. He thinks I am better than that.”
Joy Bell 


.___________________________________________________________________________

1 Extract from “The Other – without fear, favour or prejudice” by Judge Chris N Greenland. Book site - http://theother.orgfree.com/ 
2  I'm Not Black, I'm Coloured - The Film   https://www.facebook.com/INBIC
3. See -  Ethnicity … Homo Sapiens and the Black aberration ---  http://coginito.blogspot.com/2011/02/ethnicity-homo-sapiens-and-black.html

Tuesday, September 13, 2011

Dubula ibhunu --- (Kill the Boer song) A Nation in Trouble


Julius Malema
South Africa is a constitutional democracy that came into being, with the rapturous acclaim of the whole world, as epitomizing the ultimate triumph of good over evil. In 1994 Nelson Rolihlahla Mandela stood astride an adoring world; a moral giant in his embodiment of everything that was truly good about the human spirit. Thereafter South Africa adopted a constitution, that it has touted as being the best in the world, so as to ensure that these perceptions were not just an illusion, but a reality for all of its people.
Today, 17 years later, the nation is as divided as ever. Our Black dominated government leads the Black majority in emotional rhetoric that rejects, condemns and demeans a judgment of its own court of justice. At the very heart of this angry discontent is the fact that the court has, in a judgment, sought to protect the rights and interests of a White minority. For this the Black majority is being encouraged to be deeply offended and/or angered. The exhaustively reasoned judgment of a High Court Judge, (sitting in the Equality Court) arrived at after some five months of consideration, is dismissed out of hand. He is wrong, he is wrong! ...  and is seeking to expunge Black struggle history! ... is the resounding refrain bugled right from the top.
The facts are simple. Julius Malema, controversial African National Congress Youth President, repeatedly sang a struggle song, the impact line of which is dubula ibhunu, which literally translated means “Shoot the Boer”. The term Boer has always referred to White Afrikaner farmers. AfriForum, a zealously driven White Afrikaner dominated interest group, took the issue to the Equality Court,  arguing that the singing of the song constituted hate speech as it could reasonable induce endangerment, dislike/antipathy for and/or a demeaning of its members.
  • There was no dispute that the ordinary meaning of the words, “Shoot the Boer”, in the song, constitutes hate speech. 
  • Julius Malema, and the ANC, argued that the ordinary meaning of the words should not be applied, as when the song was conceived and sung, during the struggle, it referred to “destroying the evil apartheid system” and not to the killing of White farmers. 
  • It was therefore in this “historical context” that the song was still being sung, and since no mischief was intended, its singing was not hate speech.
The Court agreed with AfriForum that the words constituted hate speech and banned the singing of the song in public or in private, ruling that it had no longer has a place in our constitutional democracy, with its legislated imperatives of nation building.

The universal response to this ruling at leadership level has been one of deep offense and anger. This nation is in trouble. It is in trouble because it is blindingly obvious that there is a complete lack of understanding of the imperatives of our constitutional democracy, particularly the most precious commodity of equality before the law. It is therefore necessary to set out, with the simplicity that characterizes truth, an explanation of the reality of our situation. Judge Colin Lamont has already set out, with commendable exhaustiveness, a jurisprudential version of this. This is for our leaders and all of us ordinary folk.
  1. When our constitution was adopted everything changed forever! 
  2.  Hostilities ended, races were reconciled and all citizens were rendered equal before the law. 
  3.  In such a situation there can be no room for any person calling for the shooting (killing) of any other person, whatever the reason. 
  4.  The fact that the words used have a particular meaning that was ascribed and applied in struggle history changes nothing as, by law, Judge Lamont was constrained to apply the “ordinary meaning” of the words. 
  5.  In doing so Judge Lamont is upholding his sworn duty under our Constitution to apply the law “without fear, favour or prejudice”. He has no option. His hands are tied. 
  6.  In any event, common sense tells us that, 17 years after the fact of the struggle there are likely to be more, not less, human beings who are totally unaware of the particular meaning that the ANC ascribes to the words. Farmers are already being killed at significant levels by criminal elements. The exhortation in the song can only make things worse. 
  7.  In giving this judgment the court has in no way “expunged ANC history”, as emotively claimed by just about all leaders of the ANC. History can never be expunged. That is a simple fact. History is just that – history. By its very nature history remains in the past. It does not exist in the present. Expunging ANC history was, and remains, an impossibility. 
  8.  In effect, the judge has ruled that the ANC cannot dredge up historical behaviour and culture so as to endanger, threaten or demean citizens to-day. 
  9.  There is nothing new about the fact that practices, behaviour, and culture that had a strong place in history are discarded, even criminalized. No one can deny that the inequality of women generally was once entrenched. Today the Constitution forbids it. One twin was killed at birth. Today that would constitute infanticide. In isiNdebele culture a baby would be killed (as a wizard/witch) if its top teeth appeared first. That too is now classified as murder. There are many other examples. 
  10.  Conversely White Afrikaners are debarred from preaching that Blacks were Biblically ordained to be “hewers of wood and drawers of water” which was their culture, used to underpin the evil apartheid system. Preaching that now would undoubtedly be classified as hate speech. 
  11.  Like the song in question all these historical practices are now part of history. Whether they can or cannot be invoked is a matter of law as applied under our “World beating” Constitution, however much we may be emotionally or romantically attached to that historical practice.
It is as simple as that. Hence the tragedy of rampant misunderstanding at leadership level. A Court of Justice is now being portrayed as traitorous. One revered political commentator even  adverted to the fact that Judge Lamont was of apartheid vintage. Such talk and posturing is highly irresponsible and dangerous.

The nation is in trouble. If our leaders do not understand the realities of a constitutional democracy we are in serious trouble. The danger is of new tyrannies becoming manifest on account of a culture of “might is right”. 

The extent to which minorities are protected is a sure indicator of the extent to which a country is strong or weak on social justice and human rights. History has repeatedly shown that the majority are often wrong. That is why we have courts to ensure protection of all, and equality under the law. The seeming contempt with which a carefully considered judgment of a court of justice is being rejected undermines the very essence of our constitutional democracy. The courts are being brought into disrepute and the rule of law subverted.

Leadership, represented by President Jacob Zuma, gave solemn undertakings that the decision of the Courts would be respected. This decision is being visited with disrespect and contempt as evidenced by Malema's unchallenged statements that the Court seeks to take South Africa back to apartheid days.  The whole approach appears ton be fueled by a belief that because the ANC community prefers something else, the decision "must be wrong". 

Might is not right! history has repeatedly proved this. In South Africa we have the very significant precedent that the vast majority hold to the view that capital punishment is not just desirable, but an imperative. The Courts ruled otherwise. Government led the nation in acceptance of this ruling! However, it now fails to see that it is simply wrong to reject another decision by the court because the latest decision is politically ":inconvenient".

Will everyone please take a step back, take a deep breath and quietly and soberly reflect on these realities. 
_________________________________________________________________________


PS: Professor Steven Friedman makes a seemingly good point that it would be better not to have a ban but allow people to openly trade insults as banning breeds resentment.
True -- very true -- for mature democracies!! Africa is quite a different matter ... and actual experience has shown how inter racial/tribal "labeling" can result in situations as bad as genocide. Judge Lamont understandably adverted to this. 
In South Africa we have already had a horrific saga of xenophobic violence because foreigners were linked to social injustice -- just as Malema is linking the Boers to subsisting dispossession and economic disadvantage. 

PPS: 
An Australian court has ruled that articles on fair skinned Aboriginals contravened their Racial Discrimination Act.
The articles, which were published in 2009, were headlined "It's so hip to be black'' and "White fellas in the black''.
Federal Court Justice Mordy Bromberg found that fair-skinned Aboriginal people were reasonably likely to have been "offended, insulted, humiliated or intimidated by the imputations conveyed'' in two articles written by Mr Bolt. 
This case is of relevance to South Africa's consideration of the Malema "Kill the Boer" court saga. Our Judge Lamont appears to be vindicated.
Free counters!