Thursday, June 30, 2011

Thinking like a Black --- or like a White --- cogito, ergo sum

Apart from too often dredging up the past when discussing current


issues we also find that there is now an entrenched tactic to characterize an unwelcome view as either “not thinking like a Black” or “White thinking”.  The phenomenon is well represented on social networks and comments on news items.
Since not all human beings are black the stance is inherently racist. At the very start of the discourse ethnically different participants are challenged to accept that their thinking is flawed and that they are incapable of understanding, purely on the basis of their ethnicity. Since the dominant group in South Africa is Black, it is a bully boy tactic, designed to intimidate.
It is intended to place the attacker in a position of higher moral ground of righteous aggrievement; to induce a guilt complex in the opponent about the past; to create a psychological border over which stones can then be thrown.
The motive for this tactic is obvious, crude and rather bemusing. However, it is effective in achieving the objectives of the adherents of this approach. Simply put, it is a classic example of “playing the man, and not the ball”. By labeling your opponent you immediately distract everyone from the real issue and start a process of discrediting your opponent instead. Once the “dog has a bad name, no one will listen to its bark”. Because the attack is racialised it is particularly appealing to so many who, understandably, have unresolved issues on this score.
So as regards a person of mixed race pedigree problems are immediate. When a Coloured person points out the fact that he/she is obviously not Black the artful response is that “Black is a state of mind”.  What then as regards a coloured person who sees him/herself as Coloured or even White? Out comes labeling and insults. Such a person has a mind “that was colonized’; “imperialistic”; “polluted” … etc.
There is also a far more sinister purpose behind this type of insistence. Requiring people to be constrained to "conformist" thinking (that of the dominant majority) is a tool of tyrants and despots. A situation is created where people are not allowed to question, to ask, to query, to have their own opinions and think for themselves. The "great leader" or the governing party does "all the thinking for all the people". Anybody who dares think for themselves is labeled "anti-revolutionary"; "reactionary"; “traitor"; “sellout" ... etc and liable for victimization. This was the culture of the 3rd Reich. It is the culture of North Korea. It is what I have personally experienced in South Africa.
So everyone needs to take a step back, take a deep breath, and examine the proposition that is routinely peddled without challenge. What exactly is it to “think like a Black”? Do Black folk think in binary code? Is the cognitive process ensconced in a skull covered by a black skin different from the rest of humanity? As you pose these questions, and so many suggest themselves, you are struck as to how absurd the thing is.
You quickly realize that you either think or you don’t. That is exactly why the great philosophers had little difficulty with the proposition by René Descartes that cogito, ergo sum, i.e. “I think therefore I am”. In short, it is the ability to think that just about completely defines us human beings and distinguishes us from other animals.
What is particularly nauseating is that you do not find other ethnic groups indulging in this nonsense. Even racist Whites do not advocate that anybody should “think like a White”. You will find no such rubbish in Indian, Chinese, Malaysian, Japanese, French …. etc… discourse. It is only some of our Black brothers that are imbued with the notion that there is such a thing as “thinking like a Black” or “thinking like a White”.
So we have an obscene pantomime of a certain Professor Jonathan Moyo, architect of anti-media laws in Zimbabwe, telling the World that he is a "Pan Africanist" (our biggest conformist camp) on Africa 360, dressed in shoes, suit and tie of completely European vintage. Sigh! Let us think it through. Should the World therefore have “Pan Japaneeism; Pan Frenschism ….?” Come to think of it with all its drug use the United States should be not “Pan but Pot Americanism”. The tea drinking Chinese should be “Kettle Chineseism”. You really have to be a sheep on Animal Farm, and one of the really dumb ones at that, not to see how nonsensical this is. 
I have little doubt that members of this camp will immediately seek to counter my stance by advancing a rather silly, but otherwise pernicious, ancillary label – “coconut”. A “coconut” is a label attaching to any member of mixed race pedigree who declines to “think like a Black” and is therefore brown on the outside but “white” inside, like a coconut.
You don’t know whether to laugh or cry … really! Anthropologically all human beings are classified as homo sapiens, i.e., possessed of intellect. Intellect is obviously “colourless”. Oprah Winfrey has achieved spectacular success in using her mind efficiently and effectively. So has Barrack Obama and millions of other persons of colour. There was nothing “black” or “white” in their cognitive processes as they made their successful journeys of life.
Albert Einstein, Madame Curie, Edison, Pasteur …. and so many others that have advanced the course of humanity, did this by thinking ... using their cognitive processes to see things for what they are ... un-coloured and un-cluttered by racial thinking!
Abraham Lincoln was not black. However, he was able to reason that slavery was simply wrong. What type of thinking was the "white" electorate indulging in when they elected Barrack Obama? It is, of course pertinent to point out that the culture of the "thinking like a Black" camp is the very antithesis of what Martin Luther King Jr advocated in his immortal "I have a Dream" speech. It is also the antithesis of what Nelson Rolihlahla Mandela advocated in his “Never Again” speech.
So let us all see this propensity of labeling other human beings and putting their minds in “racial camps” for the cowardly, nonsensical, smelly thing that it is. When you cannot deal with the substance of your opponent’s point of view, you dredge up a discrediting label. It is extremely demeaning of humanity that this type of thinking is tolerated, acquiesced in, connived and colluded at.
Ask yourself what is going to be the position if the proponents of this insistence were to govern. The answer is self suggestive - you will not be allowed to think for yourself. Alternatively you will be condemned, persecuted and victimized for thinking differently. There will be "Thought Police" as envisaged by George Orwell in his classic work "1984". 
Let us be clear, Black Consciousness is a noble concept and state of mind, when it seeks to explain our history, including the hurts and pains, and promotes what is good about our culture like ubuntu. That is not the same as “ethnic thinking” which we need to dump. It is self demeaning. Really!
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Order --- theother.orgfree.com.



Tuesday, May 3, 2011

Osama Bin Laden - some bad even the good ....

In a clandestine operation a group of men entered a foreign country, without permission of its

government, attacked a domestic residence, killed three people including a woman, made off with the body of one of them; which they subsequently dumped in the ocean, without participation of the relatives of the deceased.
These are the facts of the matter. They were a consequence of a “wanted dead or alive” notice issued by George Bush, previous President of the united States of America.

CNN has just screened an in depth report featuring President Obama and Admiral William H. McRaven, Commander of the Navy Seals at the time, as it is the 5th anniversary of the event. 
In reaction to the raid and killing, nearly the whole world expressed approval, ranging from satisfaction, solemn exaltation to wild exuberance. We did this, even though the “Wild West” days in which men were flushed out by a posse, and killed on a wanted dead or alive notice, are long gone. 
This world is made up of mostly good people who, by and large, insist on certain sacred principles. These include the fact that -
  1. a person is presumed to be innocent until proved guilty before an independent adjudicating authority;
  2.  that extra judicial killing is murder; 
  3. that one cannot be accuser, judge/jury and executioner. 
The fact that the execution was on foreign soil, after clandestine invasion, is aggravating of the violation of these dearly held sacred beliefs and norms, embedded in a raft of dogmata called human rights. Indeed these rights are enshrined in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights signed off by nearly all governments at the United Nations in 1948 after two World Wars and the Holocaust..
That is our belief set. They are a fundamental component of what we insist on, fight for and defend, having learnt from the lessons of history. We say that anything short of this is injustice. We say that an injustice to one is an injustice to all.
"We are bound by an inescapable garment of mutuality, whatever affects one directly, affects all indirectly." 
Dr. Martin Luther King, jr.
- letter from the Birmingham Jail, 1962 -
But for the fact that the victim was Osama Bin Laden, we would have undoubtedly had an entirely opposite reaction and would have expressed negative emotions, ranging from disapproval to extreme condemnation.
In my book1 I advert to a saying that – “some are good even the bad, some are bad even the good”. The phenomenon of Bin Laden has managed to emphatically validate this saying. Many believe that bad boy Bin Laden was good.
However the vast majority of good folk the world over, have suddenly ignored/changed all of the most fundamental and sacred rules that we post at the very center of unalienable human rights. 
We have this “bad” approach because we have accepted what has been served up by the media. Bin Laden has been caricatured as the devil incarnate. At a stroke the awesome power of the media is demonstrated. It has induced an almost universal anti Bin Laden hysteria. In that hysteria we fail to distinguish what is information and what is proof beyond reasonable doubt.

We abandon all standards and our sacred beliefs. We have all accepted information from the media, not evidence, let alone proof beyond a reasonable doubt.
In the process Bin Laden, and those who died with him, accused and convicted of nothing, were divested of all their human rights … as were the 2752 innocent victims from 97 countries on 9/11, as well as so many others around the world.
The blood of the innocents cry out, not so much for justice as for vengeance.


Admiral McRaven specifically disavows vengeance as having been the motive for the raid and the killing and claims that it was about justice. So does President Obama.
As a qulaified lawyer President Obama must know that extra-judicial killing can never be about justice. It is the antithesis of justice because this Lady is left out of the picture. She is Lady Justice. She is blind to the status and repution of those that appear before her and only goes on hard evidence that must be proved in open court.
So, as much as we, good people, may profess to believe in standards that accord with a level of personal integrity that we have assigned ourselves as civilized human beings, in the end we have been forced to accept that the ancients were not wrong when they insisted on “an eye for an eye, tooth for a tooth”. *
All of the above is guaranteed once some believe that the gratuitous killing of other innocent human beings is justified in order to make a political statement. This thinking is grotesque, obscene and abhorrent on every count … and we instinctively all know that no God can approve of it.

Whatever else we might imagine; mankind is as barbaric as ever.
________________________________________________________________________
1The Other –without fear, favor or prejudice. (See - http://theother.orgfree.com/)
* a further point made in the book

Tuesday, April 5, 2011

Affirmative Action Is Racism ... by Dr Peter Hammond

Only Biblical Christianity offers a rational basis for opposing racism and for pursuing justice.
Equality before the Law is a Biblical principle:“The community is to have the same rules for you and for the alien living among you; this is a lasting ordinance for the generations to come. You and the alien shall be the same before the Lord. The same laws and regulations will apply both to you and to the alien living among you.”
Num 15:15-16 “Do not pervert justice; do not show partiality to the poor or favouritism to the great, but judge your neighbour fairly.”
Jesus Christ
Leviticus 19:15 “There is neither Jew nor Greek, slave nor free, male nor female, for you are all one in Christ Jesus.”
Galatians 3:28“For He Himself is our peace Who has made the two one and has destroyed the barrier, the dividing wall of hostility.”
 Ephesians 2:14 “From one man He made every nation of men…”
Acts 17:26 “Therefore, if anyone is in Christ, he is a new creation; the old has gone, the new has come! All this is from God who reconciled us to Himself through Christ and gave us the ministry of reconciliation: that God was reconciling the world to Himself in Christ, not counting men's sins against them. And He has committed to us the message of reconciliation.”
2 Corinthians 5:17-19 “Love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your mind and with all your strength…love your neighbour as yourself.”
Mark 12:30-31 Before the coming of Christ, the heathen nations despised honest work and consigned it to slaves. When Christ was born, half of the population of the Roman Empire were slaves. Three quarters of the population of Athens were slaves. 
But Jesus revolutionised labour. By taking up the axe, the saw, the hammer and the plane, our Lord imbued labour with a new dignity. Christianity undercut slavery by giving dignity to work. By reforming work Christianity transformed the entire social order. Our Lord Jesus Christ began His ministry in Nazareth with these words: “The Spirit of the Lord is on Me…to proclaim freedom for the prisoners…and release to the oppressed.”
Luke 4:18 When the Apostle Paul wrote to Philemon concerning his escaped slave, he urged him to welcome back Onesimus “no longer as a slave, but…as a dear brother…as a man and as a brother in the Lord.”
Philemon 16: Because of these and other Scriptural commands to love our neighbour, to be good Samaritans and to do for others what you would want them to do for you, Christians like St. Patrick, William Wilberforce, John Newton, William Carey, David Livingstone, Lord Shaftsbury and General Charles Gordon, and so many others, worked tirelessly to end the slave trade, stop child labour and set the captives free. Amongst all the religions of the world, only Christianity brought an end to the slave trade. On the other hand, those who hold to Darwin's theory of evolution, have no objective basis with which to counter racism. In fact, Darwinian Evolutionism has inspired a whole host of racist ideologies and movements including Communism. The actual title of Darwin's famous evolutionary book is: “On the origin of species by means of natural selection, or the preservation of favoured races in the struggle for life.”
Karl Marx wanted to dedicate “Das Kapital” to Charles Darwin and wrote “Darwin's book is very important and serves me as a basis in the natural sciences for the historical class struggle.” “
Violence is the midwife…” As Stalin so succinctly put it: “Evolution leads to revolution.”
Both Darwin and Marx expressed racist views. It is ironic that so many Russians and Africans have held Marxist beliefs, because Marx himself despised the Slavs and the Blacks, writing that they were “frozen at pre-civilisation levels” and would never make any contribution to history!
(Karl Marx The Racist, 1978; Understanding The Times, David Noebel, 1991; Marx and Satan, Richard Wurmbrand). “They promise them freedom, while they themselves are slaves of depravity…” 2 Peter 2:19
The Oxford English Dictionary defines racism as: “…discrimination against or antagonism towards other races.” 
Yet many who speak out vitriolicly against racism, are themselves racist, displaying intense antagonism towards people of other races, and advocating policies which discriminate on the basis of race. 
These are many of the same people who would respect Martin Luther King, but who are not willing to live by his maxim: “They will not be judged by the colour of their skin, but by the content of their character.” 
Frustrated people easily give in to character conditioned hate. The easiest idea to sell anyone is that he is better than someone else. The holocaust in Rwanda where mobs of Hutus slaughtered over 800 000 Tutsi Christians is just one example of the destructive power of tribalism in Africa today. More people were killed with machetes in six weeks in Rwanda, than have been killed by nuclear weapons in all of history. 
H.G. Wells noted that racism “justifies and holds together more baseness, cruelty and abomination than any other sort of error in the world.” 
Abraham Heschel described racism as “the maximum of hatred for a minimum of reason.” 
It is disturbing how many African leaders, while ostensibly opposing racism support one of the most vitriolic racists on the continent today: Robert Mugabe. 
Despite Zimbabwean dictator, Robert Mugabe, being guilty of some of the most vicious racism with a disastrous policy of state sponsored terrorism, the stealing and looting of farms and businesses, murder of farmers and opposition members, terrorising of supreme court justices, bombing of opposition newspaper offices, imprisoning of critics and reckless promotion of racial hatred against whites and Jews, the ANC government of South Africa steadfastly refuses to criticise Mugabe. 
The crisis in Zimbabwe is severe. People are dying of starvation in a man made famine, orchestrated by the ZANU-PF government of Robert Mugabe. Thousands of productive farms have been seized by government organised mobs. Vast herds of cattle and wildlife have been slaughtered. Crops and stores burned. Farmhouses looted. Many people beaten or murdered. 
One of the most productive agricultural economies in Africa has been systematically destroyed because of fanatical racial hatred. Not only did these farms feed the entire nation, but they also exported food, providing the highest percentage of foreign exchange earnings. These commercial farms were also the largest employers of labour in the country and provided homes for up to 4 million farm workers and their dependants. 
Yet, the President of Zimbabwe, Robert Mugabe, needing a scapegoat for his failed socialism, played the race card and declared: “Farmers are enemies of the state!… We have degrees in violence!…I will be a Black Hitler - 10 fold!…Those farmers who resist will die!” 
During the March 2002 Presidential Election in Zimbabwe over 1 400 MDC election observers and supporters were arrested in a massive nation wide clamp down on the opposition. Human rights groups documented over 70 000 human rights abuses in the run up to the elections. This included severe beatings, abductions, torture and murder. ZANU-PF officials, supporters, war veterans and youth brigade militia rampaged through residential areas, attacking people indiscriminately, beating street vendors, dragging white farmers from their cars, savagely beating and murdering many. 
Yet, although almost all observers condemned the elections as fraudulent, incredibly, the African National Congress (ANC) government of South Africa expressed their “warm congratulations” to Robert Mugabe for “a convincing majority win.” 
Many condemned the ANC's “obscene haste” to declare the poll legitimate, even before all the reports had come in. When the head of the South African Observer Commission declared the elections “legitimate” and brushed aside the widespread murder, violence, abduction and torture of observers and massive irregularities, he was jeered by journalists and diplomats alike. When questioned about the disenfranchisement of hundreds of thousands of voters in Zimbabwe, the ANC official dismissed it as “an administrative oversight!” Journalists laughed out loud, stood up and walked out in disgust. 
“Whoever says to the guilty, you are innocent - peoples will curse him and nations denounce him.” Proverbs 24:24 
It is evident that this blind support for Mugabe is inspired, in large part, by racial prejudice. Despite Mugabe engineering one of the most “spectacular economic collapses in history” with his national suicide of Zimbabwe, all too many black political leaders support him - irrespective of the lawlessness and savagery afflicting the population of Zimbabwe. 
This racism and hypocrisy was also evident at the UN World Summit hosted in South Africa. Even while Mugabe's supporters were slaughtering endangered wildlife and destroying huge forests and game reserves in Zimbabwe, Mugabe was being applauded as a key note speaker at the World Summit on Sustainable Development! Some of the greatest game reserves in Africa have been in Zimbabwe. Now many of these wildlife sanctuaries are scenes of unprecedented slaughter. Along with the wholesale poaching, marxist mobs have been engaged in wholesale theft, abductions and murder. Properties have been burned out, tourists have been chased out of safari camps and game rangers have been assaulted and even killed.
“How long will the land lie parched and the grass in every field be withered? Because those who live in it are wicked, the animals and birds have perished.” Jeremiah 12:4 
Under Mugabe even judges have been assaulted by mobs in their chambers in court, journalists and editors have been arrested and tortured, pastors have been arrested for praying for peace and justice, and the only independent daily newspaper and radio station in Zimbabwe have been blown up. 
“Destructive forces are at work in the city; threats and lies never leave its streets.” Psalm 55:11 
How can anybody in the ANC ever again speak against the racial discrimination of “apartheid South Africa”, when they have instituted their own racial discrimination through affirmative action in South Africa and are so enthusiastically supportive of Robert Mugabe's vicious racism in Zimbabwe? 
Dr Peter Hammond
“Woe to those who call evil good and good evil, who put darkness for light and light for darkness…who are wise in their own eyes…who acquit the guilty for a bribe, but deny justice to the innocent…for they have rejected the Law of the Lord Almighty…” Isaiah 5:20-24 
Dr Peter Hammond is the author of In The Killing Fields of Mozambique, Holocaust in Rwanda, and Faith Under Fire in Sudan.  

Friday, April 1, 2011

Judicial Service Commission … political renting?

The Supreme Court of Appeal, South Africa, (SCA) has lambasted the Judicial Service Commission (JSC)
for attempting to brush the John Hlophe issue under the carpet.
What happened is that two Constitutional Court Judges had alleged that Hlophe attempted to influence them in an upcoming hearing on a matter involving Jacob Zuma, then a presidential candidate; now President. As a result all of the Judges of the Constitutional Court had signed a letter formally laying a complaint of an attempt by Hlophe to pervert the course of justice in violation of our Constitution. Hlophe filed a counter complaint of victimization. Both claims remain unproven.
Judge John Mandlakayise Hlophe is perceived as a champion of Black interests in the ANC camp. Not surprisingly, therefore, his cause was taken up within the camp, and the Constitutional Court Judges, and their complaint came under vociferous attack. A "Justice For Hlophe Alliance" was formed.
Under the Constitution the JSC has a duty to adjudicate complaints properly laid against a judge. The nation awaited its decision with bated breath.
The JSC did not adjudicate the matter. It concluded that it was unable to do so. Its reasoning was that any hearing on the matter would be a waste of time, as it would never be able to decide the truth of the matter, given Hlophe’s denial. It is to state the obvious to say that when a person is accused of misconduct, civil or criminal, the fact the he/she denies it can never preclude/disable an adjudicating body from having a hearing and deciding where the truth is. Courts, tribunals and other fora all over the world, are daily faced with situations of dispute.  Deciding truth is the very essence of adjudication. So, in simple terms, the JSC decided to funk out of its duty. The SCA has said as much. The question is Why? Why did the JSC decide to abdicate its duty to decide whether or not Judge John Hlophe was guilty?
What happened inevitably induced a perception that Hlophe’s enormous political stature, and perceived connections to the now very powerful Jacob Zuma camp, influenced the JSC and triggered their dysfunction. In terms of this view, it is really a no brainer, given how obviously wrong their funk was? John Mandlakayise Hlophe had the political currency to save him. The JSC was prepared to deal in it. It is called political renting. Is this the culture at the JSC?
I (Chris Greenland) appeared before the JSC to be interviewed as to my suitability for appointment as a judge. As the interview started, Commissioner Julian Von Klemperer (picture on right) stated –“Mr. Chairman we are opposing confirmation of this candidate as a judge”. 
The interview had hardly begun … and here was a commitment by a camp, because that is what the use of the word “we” must mean, to oppose my candidature whatever my performance in the interview.  There had been a complaint that Von Klemperer "did not apply its mind" to the issue in the process involving adjudication of the Hlophe matter. This is exactly what Von Klemperer was now doing as regards my candidature ...  not applying his mind to the process but prosecuting an agenda instead!
Klemperer camp was making it clear that he and others on the Commission had already made up their minds. An interview was a waste of time. Coincidentally Hlophe tried unsuccessfully to have Von Klemperer removed from the JSC panel due to adjudicate the complaint about him. 
In support of this agenda against me, because that is what it was, Von Klemperer served up a monstrous lie, and produced a false transcript of court proceedings over which I had presided, in order to support the lie. Despite my protestations that the accusation was preposterous the attack was allowed. See media report …
In doing so, he admitted that it was an “ambush”, as I had not been given any notice of his accusations. It is an established practice of the JSC that candidates are given timeous notice of concerns.
Thereafter there was no interview, as the matters covered could never have informed any reasonable person as to my suitability for a judgeship. For instance, it was muted that Robert Mugabe had appointed me as a judge as an act of “reconciliation”.
Quite obviously if members of an adjudicating authority make it clear at the start of the process that they are not going to accept your candidature, whatever you might have to say, the subsequent interview is a sham. Permitting the ambush, and the marginal relevance of the questions that followed, simply confirmed the process as a complete sham.
In a subsequent communication to the JSC, both the complete falsity of the accusation and the transcript, advanced by Von Klemperer, were proved beyond any shadow of doubt. The further obvious point was made that the falsehoods had been advanced in terms of an artfully crafted agenda, at the heart of which had been the production of a false transcript. Since the court had been jam-packed with lawyers and advocates, at the time I presided over it, all these “officers of the court” had not heard me say what Von Klemperer served up to the JSC. And yet the lies had been served up all the same.
The glaringly obvious point was made that to serve up lies to the JSC, in order to mislead it in its sacred duty to assess a candidate for the office of judge, was subversive of our constitution. The further point was made that, in terms of evidence, manifest before and after the interview, it was clear that the motive behind the whole scam was to block my appointment, as I was perceived as being pro public in Road Accident Fund matters. The Chief Justice, Pius Langa,  confirmed, after many months of insistence for an answer, that the falsehood had emanated from the Eastern Cape Society of Advocates.
Advocates are officers of the court. By any test, lying by an advocate to a public body is serious. Lying to the JSC, a constitutional organ of State, could not be more serious. It is of interest to note for instance –
The Judicial Service Act (Ch 14) of Uganda, S 21 –
“Any person who, in connection with the exercise by the commission of its functions, wilfully gives to the commission any information which he or she knows to be false or does not believe to be true, or which he or she knows to be false by reason of the omission of any material particular, commits an offence and is liable on conviction to a fine not exceeding thirty currency points or to imprisonment not exceeding twelve months or to both.”
Lying in order to block the appointment of a shortlisted candidate to the office of judge is indescribably serious. It is a subversion of the Constitution, as it obviously disables the JSC from making a competent assessment of a candidate.
This occurred in October 2008. To date the JSC has done absolutely nothing about the matter. The miscreants are known. What they did stands proved beyond doubt. Why? Why has this matter of most serious implications been also swept under the carpet?
The answer appears from the facts of the incident itself. As said, Von Klemperer was allowed to commit to a stance on behalf of a constituency, even before I was interviewed. The JSC then contented itself with what was now a sham interview.
What this means is that the operational culture of the JSC was to permit its own members to commit to endorsing or blocking a candidate for a judgeship on behalf of a faceless patron, cabal, constituency or person. Judges are then selected on the basis of the strength of that patron, cabal, constituency or person, i.e., political currency.
The judge, so selected, is then beholden to whoever ensured his/her appointment. The independence of the judiciary is thereby rendered somewhat elusive. Nothing could be more serious.
If this young democracy is being made subject to political renting at the very heart of its constitutional organs and institutions, it is already perniciously betrayed. What is of particular concern is that the country's most senior judges and advocates serve on the JSC.


And what have I done about this gross injustice? Recorded it in a book for all posterity to know how you fare in South Africa when you have no political currency to trade in; 
and how Nelson Mandela's dream came to be betrayed.. 
At least truth will endure.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Order --- http://www.lulu.com/shop/chris-greenland/the-other-without-fear-favour-or-prejudice/paperback/product-23302259.html




Monday, March 28, 2011

Corruption and crime in South Africa … quo vadis

Dr Mamphela  Ramphele, an outstanding human being and member of the Mo Ibrahim Foundation, pointedly reminds South Africans that “passivity over corruption imperils our constitution” in an article published in the Sunday Times on 27 2011 March. See -  It  is relatively easy for her to prove the case of rampant corruption and functional deviance … and the list is quite endless.

Her real point is that of our shared “passivity”. Apart from grumbling now and then we are not disposed towards actually addressing the matter in any sensible way. Patricia de Lille, our most ardent and courageous advocate on this score, has actually incurred significant resentment and demonization as a result, with hardly a squeak of protest from the rest of us.

The question is why? Why do we have rampant corruption? And why are we so passive and accommodating about it.?
The answer is – anomie. Anomie is a word  popularized by French sociologist Émile Durkheim in his influential book Suicide (1897). In simple terms, anomie is present when there is a breakdown or absence of a common set of social norms and behavioral  codes that citizens are sufficiently bound to so as to respect them.  The populace interacts in a climate of “social norm confusion”. The debates on the “kill the boer” saga prove this beyond doubt.
An aspect of  anomie is that, particularly in revolutionary times, people will a) re-identify their goals and b) re-identify the means of achievement. So typically the unskilled worker who would have previously been prepared to work for 25 years and retire with his gold watch to a modest pension, will now aspire to a driving a BMW, obtained with use of a 9mm parabellum. A central aspect is that deviance and crime becomes rampant. In South Africa deviance and crime are now  pandemic.

It is very common to find a constant wail of lament about the crime situation in the country. This emanates from members off the middle to upper socio economic bracket. Complaints about robbery, murder, rape, hijackings … etc … are understandably never ending … as the levels of these crimes are indeed now legendary.  This same camp, to which most of us belong, also calls for more effective policing and harsher penalties to deal with the criminals and crime, and we lambast government for not doing enough.

Government itself, in response to this clarion call, has responded by beefing up the police, to the extent of even militarizing the police. So we now have “Generals” and “Colonels” in the police force. These bright sparks even want the law changed so that they “can shoot to kill” the criminals that are besieging society.
With respect, this well meaning response by government, and the calls that triggered it are incredibly naïve. It is naïve because it simply ignores the fundamental driver of crime … which is anomie! In fact the whole situation is somewhat farcical.
In this, with respect, we are all complicit. We are complicit on any number of counts. For present purposes we need only recognize that a) we do not have shared values and behavioral codes; and b) we have done little to achieve reconciliation and racial unity and perhaps most importantly c) we ourselves indulge in deviance at all levels.
Deviance is a national pandemic! Carte Blanche exposes this week in week out. It presents at all levels and across all racial groupings. At the bottom of the spectrum we have postal workers stealing. At the top we have the “elite of the elite” fixing national commodity food prices. In between you have crooked mechanics, dodgy lawyers, scummy estate agents, corrupt police officers … etc. The list is actually quite endless. The deviance encompasses everything from functional deviance (bad /appalling service) to gross criminal conduct. The deviant road use culture that is the driver of our appalling road use record demonstrates all of the above in microcosm.

The point is that this deviance permeates all levels of our society and presents as a pandemic, far bigger in scale than the hijackings, rapes and robberies that we all scream about! We are indeed a thoroughly anomic society … and this is the fundamental driver of the very crime (and business/governmental dysfunction) that we cry so loudly about.
Here is the rub. No social scientist or criminologist will disagree with any of the above. That is how simply true it is.
What is very  disturbing is that this is not rocket science. It is certainly not exotic academic mumbo jumbo. All legal experts, worth their salt, will know this and have known it from the time of independence, especially as apartheid undoubtedly predisposed us to the condition. Despite this there has been no evidence that government is aware of this. There has been no indication that it has been so advised. There is a total absence of appropriate strategy(s).

What is the solution?

Like any addiction we must first accept and admit that we are indeed a society that is inflicted with a widespread deviant culture – at all levels … and stop just pointing fingers, polishing our halos and having hissy fits about “others”.

When the connected elite go on a swanee to New York, on pretence that they are attending a Human Rights conference, it is fraud .. on a massive scale. When no sanction is then imposed we are actually admitting to the criminal underworld that we are “cut from the same cloth”. The deviant mindset is once again reinforced. We have a plethora of such “passivity” examples. The systemic hypocrisy by the “advantaged” sector has to stop. For goodness sake, we have a police commissioner sentenced to 15 years. We have had a president who brazenly protected a convicted thief and kept her on as a minister. Why should the “poor” hijackers and robbers feel any incentive to  desist? The fish does indeed rot from the head.

Then we need to assemble a cluster of social scientist and criminologists to devise a “national plan” to address the problem. The call by Dr Ramphele for the setting up of an independent anti corruption agency, with teeth, will then present as  just one of a raft of measures that we all need to be involved in … in our homes, schools, workplace, boardrooms … etc.

There has to be a national effort, with all citizens taking ownership, encouraged by the fact that we are all saying mea culpa and not just bitching, moaning and pointing fingers. A shared acknowledgement will also be a powerful precipitant to fostering national unity, especially as it will include the admission that the poor suffer the most as a result.

What If we Don’t

If we do not address the issue of anomie, more crime, bad service and carnage on our roads is guaranteed … whatever we and our well meaning “General” Bheki Cele and his squad of official hit men may imagine. As Ramphele and Archbishop Tutu have already said we need to “walk together”. It is as simple as that. Finish and klaar …. 

Saturday, March 12, 2011

Racism in South Africa … unconscionably signed off by the ANC government?

In other blog posts I have strongly lamented the fact, and the law, that we have used race/ethnicity/skin colour as the central criteria to redress disadvantage in our transformational model. Under a raft of laws and protocols our Affirmative Action model is predicated on the proposition that, before you can receive assistance to redress apartheid induced disadvantage, you must be Black or accept the label “Black”. Also see ......
I have made the point that we now have a nation that is obsessed and preoccupied, in its psyche, with racial/ethnic difference, with dastardly consequences looming, particularly for our children in their formative years. A reality check is to advert to America, a country we just love to pooh pooh and posture against. The comparison is that, in South Africa, it is absolutely inconceivable that any "non-black" could be considered  for presidency, for a nano second. The Whites in the USA have installed a Coloured president, referred to as "black" in terms of a social construct -- NOT LAW.
I even circulated a New Years Appeal to all opinion makers in South Africa. This was, like the problem itself, simply ignored without acknowledgement.
Regrettably my stance has now been spectacularly vindicated. It has emerged that Jimmy Manyi, Chief government spokesman, made a statement on 9 March 2010 that – it is “very important for Coloured people to understand that there was an over concentration of them in the Western Cape” … and that “they should stop this over –concentration situation as they are in an oversupply situation” where they are and should move out to other Provinces. He finishes by stating the Employment Equity Act is a very good Act. See youtube…
This statement could not be more racist on a very obvious test. Each Province has an ethnic group that is in the majority, such as the Zulus in Kwa Zulu, Natal and the Xhosa in the Eastern Cape. However it is only the Coloured majority in the Western Cape that is seen as a bad problem, so bad as to negate/subvert socio-economic transformation.
A whole people, who have been in South Africa from the beginning, are classified as a problem for South African society - simply on account of their ethnicity.
There is no conceptual difference in this stance and that taken by the 3rd Reich against the Jews … and that led to the Holocaust. In both cases the ethnicity of the people is the objection. In both cases that ethnicity is classified as inimical to national interest. The only difference is that Hitler exterminated the Jews. Manyi insists that the Coloureds must migrate. Did Manyi dream this up as Idi Amin did in August 1972? Given a choice, would he resort to the same "solution" as Amin? Well, it is almost the same. Amin's solution was an expulsion of Indians from Uganda. Manyi's solution is "migration" of Coloured folk.
To see people as a problem for the national interest, as if they are plague carrying vermin, is the worst form of racism. Typically, non other than Zwelinzima Vavi of COSATU, and many others have confirmed this obvious fact. See
Manyi is our government spokesperson. Our government is the guarantor of the Constitution, that includes a Bill Of Rights, ensuring equality before the law. He has torn this up by making it clear that Coloureds are not equal before the law. They must be discriminated against. Unlike Zulus of Xhosa, and other dominant groups in other provinces, their ethnicity is a bad problem for national interest.
 It gets worse. One month after this vile attack on Coloureds, Manyi had this to say about Indians whilst addressing the Durban Chamber of Commerce
 "Indians, we should be having only 3% [of positions on management]. They are sitting at 5.9. I call it the power of bargaining. Indians have bargained their way to the top." This was said during the year that the country was supposedly celebrating 150 years of Indians having arrived in South Africa.  See …
It gets very much worse. Instead of taking action against Manyi, and/or his statements, Government took action in support by drafting an Employment Equity Amendment Bill that will have the effect of forcing migration of Coloureds out of the Western Cape as an estimated +- million of them will become unemployed. 
From this it is clear that Manyi was expressing the accepted view of a government “think tank” or “brains trust,” charged with responsibility to come up with a solution to the “Coloured problem”. The solution is the Bill.
Although government is now backtracking on the Bill, on account of widespread criticism by Unions in particular, this does not remove the truth of the whole saga. Coloureds were officially seen as a problem, purely on account of their ethnicity. Government decided that action needed to be taken. A Bill was drawn up and signed off by the whole of Cabinet, including Trevor Manuel who ironically now publicly labels only Manyi as a racist, but significantly includes the charge that – “I have a sense that your racism has infiltrated the highest echelons of government.”
Idi Amin expelled the Indians. Our government proposed to force Coloured migration!
 The Democratic Alliance could not be more right. If there is any doubt that government is fully complicit is this racism, it is completely removed by the fact that Manyi is still in his job, despite widespread calls for his removal.
 There can be very little doubt that the "anti Coloured" stance is also informed by the fact that they have voted the DA into power in the Western Cape. This exercise of a basic right to choose one's leaders is seen as offensive, unpalatable, anathema in our young democracy.  It is so, even though so many gave their lives in order to ensure we now have that sacred right. The situation could not be more vomitus!
 The Bill is, in effect, a form of pernicious social engineering to ensure that the Coloured vote is diluted to the extent that they become a racial minority in a province that they have been the majority in from day one.
At the time of independence, led by Nelson Rolihlahla Mandela, South Africa straddled the whole world as a moral giant and example to mankind.  Egged on by wonderful voices like Archbishop Desmond Tutu and Dr Mamphela Aletta Ramphele, it stood to lead the world in a new social justice culture of  ubuntu.  Ubuntu was discarded and replaced by a rapacious culture of enrichment by a new elite, trading entirely on the "Black" label. The richer have gotten richer. The poorer have gotten poorer. 
 What is especially pernicious about all this is that Manyi  and government, in the Bill, have linked the Coloured and Indian issue to the extremely emotive issue of jobs. The clear message is that these ethnic groups are prejudicing the disadvantaged Black majority on this score. The historical analogy is when Mugabe linked the emotive land issue to Whites in Zimbabwe. Despite equality under the constitution of Zimbabwe, the Whites were then divested of all rights and victimized at the whim of anybody professing to be serving Black interests.
Many Coloureds and Indians imagined that accepting the "Black" label would provide equality. We should no longer be confused. Coloureds and Indians are not Black and should never have accepted the label as a precondition to benefiting under Affirmative Action and Employment Equity laws and protocols.  They are not accepted as either "Black" or as equal. They are seen as a problem, a very big problem. 
That is the inconvenient truth that is now before our eyes for the whole world to see. We are all Africans. We should be proud Africans. That much is also clear from Thabo Mbeki's epic prose "I am an African". The richness of our ethnic diversity is admitted. We cannot be coerced to deny it. We don't have to be Black to be proud and equal among equals. 
As a nation, we should have insisted that Lady Justice remain blindfolded.

Our President needs to urgently show leadership, faced with this grossest violation of human rights and subversion of our Constitution. He knows all too well what it is like to be "categorized" and victimized. Ordinary branch members of the ANC removed Thabo Mbeki, and chose him, because they saw him as epitomizing victimhood. He carries a brief for all underdogs. He made a solemn promise that he would stand up for those who are most vulnerable and would guarantee accountability.   
If Jacob Gedleyihlekisa Zuma sees himself as the President of all South Africans the least he will do is to fire Jimmy Manyi ...immediately.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
I'm for truth, no matter who tells it.
I'm for justice,
no matter who it's for or against.
Malcolm X
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Friday, March 4, 2011

Jimmy Manyi, Trevor Manuel … and Lady Justice


Manuel
Manyi
Trevor Manuel must be commended for his open letter to Jimmy Manyi, as published on 2nd March 2011. The fact that he has transparently labeled a fellow member of the new elite a racist, with the brutal simplicity that characterizes truth, is laudable in the extreme, given the prevailing culture of acquiescence amongst its members.
The problem, and it really is a problem, is that what has happened is simply a product of what South African society, led by the ANC, has conceived, embraced and embedded under the raft of laws and protocols variously titled under employment legislation. At the heart of these laws is the proposition that the criterion to redress apartheid induced disadvantage is that one must be either Black, or be labeled Black.
In short, we racialised the basic criterion for ensuring socio-economic transformation. In terms thereof it is now the position that, as regards jobs and contracts, it is the law that  –
a)      a White must be discriminated against outright;
b)      a Black must be the recipient of favourable discrimination; and
c)       and a Coloured, Indian or Chinese may be treated as a Black if he/she accepts such label.
Right there we embraced and embedded a concept that was at the very heart of apartheid culture. We adopted racism as central to our transformative model. Perhaps it was understandable. Given the prevailing polemics, perhaps it was unavoidable. The people, it seems, may not have tolerated anything less at that time. However, as history so often proves, the road to hell is paved with good intentions. Using “reverse racism” as the national transformative elixir was like using snake venom to cure the effects of the bite – inherently dangerous. The BEE brigade and “tenderpreneurs" were to prove emphatically just how dangerous.
At the same time, we proudly held up our Constitution as a standard for the whole world. It positively prohibits racial/ethnic discrimination, except that the right not to be discriminated against can be limited, but only as follows –
36. Limitation of rights
1.   The rights in the Bill of Rights may be limited only in terms of law of general application to the extent that the limitation is reasonable and justifiable in an open and democratic society based on human dignity, equality and freedom, taking into account all relevant factors, including ­
a.     the nature of the right;
b.     the importance of the purpose of the limitation;
c.     the nature and extent of the limitation;
d.     the relation between the limitation and its purpose; and
e.     less restrictive means to achieve the purpose.
2.     Except as provided in subsection (1) or in any other provision of the Constitution, no law may limit any right entrenched in the Bill of Rights.
Put quite simply, you cannot be discriminated against, unless it “is reasonable and justifiable in an open and democratic society and there isn’t a less restrictive means to achieve the same purpose”.
So do/did we have “a less restrictive means to achieve the same purpose …” that accords with what “is reasonable and justifiable in an open and democratic society based on human dignity, equality and freedom?”
The answer is a resounding Yes!  It is staring us in the face and is really a no-brainer!  It is not rocket science!
A person should be affirmed if he/she is still disadvantaged on account of the effects of apartheid.
That is logical. It is common sense. It is right. It is fair. Most of all it is not racist. Whatever your race, ethnicity or skin colour, if you are a citizen, still disadvantaged on account of apartheid, you may be affirmed! Goodbye BEE and the other corrupt stratagems that have sabotaged, not promoted, true transformation. The poor would actually be affirmed, not have their faces spat in.
The Coloured issue was always a touchstone on the issue of whether or not these AA and BEE laws/protocols bring about transformation and social justice. The stinky nature of things is proved by the simple fact that, during apartheid years, many Coloureds had to play White in order to secure socio-economic advantage. Now, by law, they have to play Black!.
It gets a lot more stinky, as we are now seeing. Let’s be reminded of this little matter -
In the aftermath of his failure to become the president of the South African Rugby Union (SARU), Mike Stofile said the elections at the annual general meeting held on Friday proved there was no place for black people in South African rugby. …."I've been saying for four years now there is no place for black people in South African rugby and this is the final nail for black people in this country. http://www.mg.co.za/article/2008-03-28-stofile-there-is-no-place-for-black-people-in-sa-rugby
Stofile said this after being beaten, in a democratic election process, by Oregan Hoskins, a Coloured, for the position of president of SARU. Mike Stofile’s stance could not have been more clear. Whatever we were imagining, under our much vaunted AA and BEE laws/protocols, Coloureds were not Black and had no right to be selected, democratic process or not,  in preference to a Black.
ANC leadership said nothing. The Human Rights Commission said nothing. The whole nation was paralyzed by this show of blatant racism.
Roberts
Now we have Kuli Roberts having to apologize for having penned a racist column about Coloured people. Kuli can be forgiven. The whole nation is obsessed with racial/ethnic difference on account of the fact that rights and privileges are granted in accordance with such difference.
The High Court was obliged, so it seems, to declare that Chinese folk were Black.
Now the ANC Government proposes bringing in a Bill to limit the number of Coloured people an employer can have in the work place in the Western Cape. For the objectives of the Bill to be achieved the so called “Coloureds are Black definition under labour law” has to be dumped. So under our marvelous, world beating Constitution, Coloured folk stand to be defined as both “Black” and “non-Black”.
All of the above is, self-evidently, nonsensical to the point of near insanity. It is vomitus stuff. Whatever else, it certainly cannot be viewed as “reasonable and justifiable in an open and democratic society based on human dignity, equality and freedom”.
It is not reasonable, but madness. It is not justifiable, but racist.
Most of all it is not based “on human dignity, equality and freedom”. It is an insidious, systemic, stinky business in which we are demeaning our humanity and thrashing the dignity of all people of Colour.
Understandably many Coloured folk have been confused on the matter. We need to understand that, as a matter of simple anthropological/genetic fact, we are not Black, just as we are not White. We are neither Negroid nor Caucasian. To say we are Black is to propagate a very “convenient untruth”.
We also need to understand that, whatever the pretence, we are not accepted as Black. We must be indebted to people like Stofile, Roberts and Manyi for being honest enough to expose a huge “inconvenient truth”.
Most importantly, we need to understand that the social and legal obsession with being Black is racist. It is a “social construct” that had its uses in the American and South African struggle for social justice, but is no longer relevant in “an open and democratic society based on human dignity, equality and freedom”.
If we continue to countenance this pernicious concept we will not be just on George Orwell’s “Animal Farm” but on the “The Plantation”, with Manyi and gang being the masters, those who embrace the Black label being “house niggers” and the rest of us being the “plantation niggers”.
When Mohamed Bouazizi, of Tunisia was tired of having his dignity trashed, he was moved to commit immolation. This brought down a government and led to a long outstanding struggle for social justice in the Arab world.
Our dignity, and rights, are being trashed. We don’t need to set ourselves on fire like Mohamed Bouazizi. We just need to take the thing to the Constitutional Court. Whatever utility the thing was perceived to have at the time it was conceived,  in 1994-6, actual experience has proved, and is proving, beyond doubt that it really has no place in our society. We voted the DA into power in the Western Cape. It has the resources to mount a constitutional challenge. As a retired High Court judge, it is my respectful stance that the racist criteria for affirmative action will not stand up, as it requires the most tortuously obscene reasoning in support.
Lady Justice
You see, we must believe that our Constitutional Court Judges will accept that there is very good reason for Lady Justice being blindfolded, and that social injustice is guaranteed once you start taking the blindfold off and asking her to see what racial, ethnical or skin colour differences there are.

Therefore speak to them in parables: because

they seeing, see not
and hearing they hear not,
neither do they understand
Mathew: 13:13
Free counters!